selling jewelry - how it works

our process

We’ve made the jewelry reselling process as easy as possible for you. Our experts have the knowledge to create a speedy appraisal, and stand ready to make you an offer on your finished gemstone jewelry and loose gems. Best of all, there is no pressure to commit to selling your jewelry. Although over 95% of our clients accept our offer, there’s never any obligation or commitment should you decline it, and we return your jewelry free of charge.

Get Paid or Trade

We offer up to 10% over our resell offer if you prefer to trade in your jewelry for credit. Our finished line of new, fine jewelry at is made with 14-18 karat gold, diamonds, precious and semi-precious gemstones. Contact us if you would prefer to receive a credit offer at

How it Works

by mail

  • Request Free & Insured Shipping

    Fill out our contact form, and you’re provided a free, prepaid FedEx label and instructions on how to safely pack and send in your diamonds, jewelry and/or gemstones for jewelry reselling. Your package will be insured.

  • We Evaluate your Items

    Once PJ Buyback receives your package, the items will be carefully inspected and evaluated by one of PJ Buyback’s expert jewelry buyers.

  • Review Offer and Receive Payment

    We will contact you with an offer. If you accept, immediate payment will be issued by check. Should you decline the offer, your item will be returned to you via free, insured mail at no cost. You can also choose to accept a trade-in credit at up to 10% over your offer to use on our new, fine gemstone jewelry at We will issue your credit and ship your new jewelry piece within 24 hours of your accepted proposal.

get started by mail

in person

  • Schedule an Appointment

    Call us at (800) 641-1277 to schedule an appointment or complete our contact form. One of our jewelry experts will contact you within 24 hours to answer any of your questions and schedule a consultation with you.

  • We Evaluate your Items

    On the day of your appointment, you will be escorted into our DFW Showroom, and a PJ Buyback buyer will thoroughly value the items you wish to sell. Each one of your pieces will be assessed separately, noting its value and history.

  • Review Offer and Receive Payment

    Our PJ Buyback buyer will make you an offer on any piece of jewelry or loose gemstones that you wish to sell. Should you accept our offer, we cut you a check on the spot. There is never any obligation or pressure should you decline the offer. If you prefer to receive trade-in credit, you may then browse our showroom for your new fine gemstone jewelry piece. If there is a difference in value, we will issue you a check or accept a credit card to deduct the balance.

Schedule a consultation